ABSTRACT
Objective:
The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between anatomical variations and the fungus ball (FB), and the association between odontogenic etiologies and the maxillary sinus FB.
Methods:
We analyzed the clinical records of 66 patients who underwent endoscopic sinus surgery for FB. The anatomical variations determined were nasal septal deviation (NSD) and direction, presence of Onodi and Haller cell, concha bullosa and lateral recess of the sphenoid sinus. Further, dental X-ray records were reviewed to detect any possible odontogenic etiologies in patients with maxillary sinus FBs.
Results:
There were 41 female and 25 male patients. Positive fungal culture was found in 60 patients (91%) and the causative fungus was Aspergillus species in all cases. The correlation between NSD and localization of the maxillary sinus FB was statistically significant (p=0.0409). Maxillary sinus FB was more common on the concave side of the NSD. Presence of dental pathologies was significantly associated with maxillary sinus FB compared to the healthy side (p=0.0011). For sphenoid sinus FB, NSD was detected in a similar number for both the affected and unaffected side and there were no significant correlations (p>0.05). However, the relationship between sphenoid sinus FB and presence of lateral recess was significant (p=0.0262).
Conclusion:
Our study revealed that the maxillary sinus FB was more common on the concave side of the deviated septum. Also, dental pathologies or a presence of dental treatment history were associated with maxillary sinus FB.
Türkçe Özet
Amaç:
Bu çalışmanın amacı, anatomik varyasyonlar ile mantar topu arasındaki ilişkiyi ve odontojenik etiyolojiler ile maksiller sinüs mantar topu arasındaki ilişkiyi araştırmaktı.
Yöntemler:
Mantar topu nedeniyle endoskopik sinüs cerrahisi uygulanan 66 hastanın klinik kayıtlarını inceledik. Belirlenen anatomik varyasyonlar nazal septal deviasyon (NSD) ve yönü, Onodi ve Haller hücresinin varlığı, konka bülloza ve sfenoid sinüsün lateral resesi idi. Ayrıca, maksiller sinüs mantar topu olan hastalarda olası odontojenik etiyolojilerin tespiti için dental grafi kayıtları gözden geçirildi.
Bulgular:
Çalışmada 41 kadın ve 25 erkek hasta vardı. Altmış hastada (%91) mantar kültürü pozitif bulundu; bu olguların tümünde etken mantar Aspergillus türü idi. NSD ile maksiller sinüs mantar topu lokalizasyonu arasındaki korelasyon istatistiksel olarak anlamlıydı (p=0,0409). Maksiller sinüs mantar topu, NSD’nin içbükey tarafında daha yaygındı. Sağlıklı tarafa göre dental patolojilerin varlığı maksiller sinüs mantar topu ile anlamlı olarak ilişkiliydi (p=0,0011). Sfenoid sinüs mantar topu için hem etkilenen hem de etkilenmeyen taraf için benzer sayıda NSD saptandı, anlamlı bir korelasyon bulunmadı (p>0,05). Ancak sfenoid sinüs mantar topu ile lateral reses varlığı arasındaki ilişki anlamlıydı (p=0,0262).
Sonuç:
Bu çalışma, maksiller sinüs mantar topunun deviye septumun içbükey tarafında daha yaygın olduğunu ortaya koydu. Ayrıca dental patolojiler veya dental tedavi öyküsü varlığı maksiller sinüs mantar topu ile ilişkilendirildi.
Introduction
Fungus balls (FBs) are chronic non-invasive accumulations of fungal elements in the sinus cavity of healthy subjects. They usually affect a single sinus and are most commonly caused by Aspergillus species (1, 2). FBs are frequently localized within the maxillary sinus, followed by the sphenoid sinus. Clinical presentation of FBs are not specific, and patients may complain of various rhinological symptoms. FBs can thereby lead to a diagnostic dilemma for clinicians and most cases are incidentally discovered by computerized tomography (CT) and/or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (3).
The pathophysiological mechanism underlying FB is not completely understood. Stammberger (4) hypothesized that nourishment of the fungus by purulent secretions from bacterial and viral superinfections initiated the pathogenesis of fungal sinusitis, followed by the growth of fungal hyphae in a low-pH environment provided by the stenosis of the ostiomeatal complex. Eloy et al. (5) proposed that sinus hypoventilation due to ostial stenosis played a significant role both in the accumulation of fungal spores and in providing anaerobic conditions for the growth of FB. On the other hand, Tsai et al. (6) argued against this hypothesis. They examined Lund-McKay scores in CT images and indicated that ostiomeatal complex dysfunction was not clearly verifiable in the appearance of FBs.
In the presented study, we aimed to investigate the possible relationships between the occurrence of FBs and the presence of different anatomical variations, and the association between odontogenic etiologies and maxillary sinus FBs.
Methods
We retrospectively reviewed the clinical records of patients affected by paranasal sinus (PNS) FB who underwent surgery at a tertiary reference center between 2008 and 2018. The definitive diagnosis was based on histopathological evaluation and/or fungal culture of the surgical specimens. Patients with chronic rhinosinusitis, invasive fungal sinusitis, or allergic fungal sinusitis or who had undergone any previous sinonasal surgery were excluded. Immunocompromised patients were also excluded. The Ethics Committee of İstanbul University İstanbul Faculty of Medicine reviewed and approved the study (project no: 1174/2019).
Preoperative endoscopic examination records, CT and MRI scans of all patients were retrieved from the medical records and reviewed retrospectively. In our clinical practice, patients with maxillary sinus FBs are evaluated with dental X-ray in term of possible odontogenic etiologies such as endodontic treatment history, periodontal disease, tooth extraction, dental implant presence, and communication between tooth apex and maxillary sinus. Therefore, dental X-rays of the patients with maxillary sinus FB were also reviewed. Accordingly, patients with dental pathology and related complaints were consulted to the oral and maxillofacial surgery department.
The anatomical variations determined were nasal septal deviation (NSD) and direction, presence of Onodi and Haller cell, concha bullosa and lateral recess of the sphenoid sinus. NSD of 10 degrees or more was accepted as a separate risk factor. NSD angle was also examined and calculated from coronal CT scans as the angle between the most deviated portion of the septum and the midline (Figure 1).
Endoscopic sinus surgery was performed under general anesthesia in all patients. Abundant sinus irrigation was done with saline solution during surgery until all fungal remains were removed. At the end of the surgery nasal packing was applied, and the packing was removed on the second postoperative day. Topical or systemic antifungal therapy were not prescribed. All patients were followed with nasal endoscopy every three months during the first postoperative year.
Results
There were 41 (62.1%) females and 25 (37.9%) male patients, with an age range of 10–84 years (mean: 45.63±17.14). Positive fungal culture was found in 60 patients (91%). The causative fungus was Aspergillus species in all cases.
The localizations of PNS FBs are summarized in Table 1. The most commonly affected sinus was the maxillary sinus (53%) followed by the sphenoid sinus (33.3%). A total of 66 patients had 70 FBs and all patients were unilateral, except for three patients (4.5%). Of these, one had bilateral maxillary sinus FB, one had bilateral sphenoid sinus FB, and one had right maxillary FB and left frontal sinus FB simultaneously.
The analysis of anatomical variations is shown in Table 2. In maxillary sinus FB, both NSD and severe NSD (≥10 degrees) were more common on the unaffected side. In other words, the concave side of the deviated septum and the direction of maxillary sinus involvement were the same. However, the relationship between severe NSD and the localization of the maxillary sinus FB was not significant (p>0.05). The maxillary sinus FB was significantly more common on the concave side of the NSD compared to the unaffected side (p=0.0409). Haller cell was detected in both the affected and the unaffected sides in maxillary sinus FB, and a statistically significant difference was not found (p>0.05). Concha bullosa was more common on the affected side in maxillary sinus FB, but this association was not statistically significant (p>0.05).
In sphenoid sinus FB, NSD and severe NSD (≥ 10°) were detected in similar numbers on both the affected and the unaffected sides and there were no significant correlations (p>0.05). Haller cell was more common on the affected side, although Onodi cell was more common on the unaffected side. However, there were no significant differences (p>0.05). Lateral recess was found in 14 of the 24 sphenoid sinuses. Eleven of these were on the same side as FB and this association was significant (Figure 2, p=0.0262).
In 35 of 38 patients who had maxillary sinus FB, 74 dental pathologies were identified on the affected sides. There were 51 dental pathologies on the unaffected sides. In three patients (3/38) with maxillary sinus FB on the affected side and 16 patients (16/38) on the unaffected side, CT scans revealed no dental pathology. Some examples of the dental pathologies are shown in Figure 3. The presence of dental pathologies on the affected side was significantly associated with FB compared to the unaffected side (p=0.0011, Fisher’s exact test) (Table 3). The most common pathologies were dental extraction (30/74, 40.5%) followed by endodontic treatment (18/74, 24.3%) and dental root in the maxillary sinus (10/74, 13.5%). The correlation between single dental pathology and FB was not significant.
Discussion
The presented study investigated the possible relationship between FBs and different anatomical variations that can cause narrowing of the sinus drainage pathway or have a negative effect on mucociliary clearance. We also evaluated dental X-rays of the patients to see whether there were any associations between odontogenic etiology and maxillary sinus FB.
NSD is a well-known anatomical variation that may lead to recurrent rhinosinusitis. Deviation of the septum to one side of the nasal cavity causes chronic influences in nasal airflow. The nasal airflow increases in the contralateral side and decreases in the ipsilateral side. Comprehensive analysis of previous studies showed that an increased angle of NSD was markedly associated with increased frequency of rhinosinusitis, especially with a NSD of 10° or more (7). Oshima et al. (8) found a significant correlation between maxillary sinus FB and NSD in male patients. They discovered that maxillary sinus FB was markedly common on the concave side of the NSD in male patients. Why this association was observed only in males is not clear, but the authors speculated that the relatively larger size of the male nasal cavity could be more sensitive to nasal airflow and its negative effects. Hwang et al. (9) described a statistically positive correlation between larger volume of the middle meatus and maxillary sinus FB. Also, they found no significant relationship between NSD and FB, or the nasal valve area and FB. In our study, a significant correlation between NSD and maxillary sinus FB was observed. Maxillary sinus FB was markedly common on the concave side of the nasal septum. However, the same correlation was not found in patients who had severe NSD. Chen et al. (10) detected increased turbulence and velocity in the middle meatal region on the concave side of the nasal septum. The traumatic effects of turbulent nasal airflow on the concave side can cause ostial stenosis and mucociliary dysfunction due to mucosal injury. Ostial stenosis and decreased mucociliary clearance can result in accumulation of fungal spores and development of FB in the sinus cavity.
Concha bullosa is known as middle turbinate pneumatization, which is associated with recurrent rhinosinusitis due to possible negative effects on both sinus ventilation and mucociliary clearance in the middle meatus (11). However, the role of concha bullosa in maxillary sinusitis development is controversial. In a review study, the presence of concha bullosa in the beginning or the sustaining of rhinosinusitis was not identified as being very important (12). In contrast, Caughey et al. (13) noted a significant association between concha bullosa and maxillary sinusitis. Oshima et al. (8) investigated a possible correlation of different anatomical variations and maxillary sinus FB. Interestingly, they discovered that concha bullosa formation was more prevalent on the healthy side, but this difference was not significant. Tsai et al. (6) reported that there was no structural relationship between concha bullosa and PNS FB. In our study, unlike Oshima et al. (8), concha bullosa was more common on the affected side with maxillary sinus FB. However, a significant correlation was not found between concha bullosa and maxillary sinus FB.
Haller cell is known as infraorbital air cell, which expands from the ethmoid cavity into the maxillary sinus. This air cell may prevent both pneumatization and drainage of the maxillary sinus, hence it can cause recurrent maxillary sinusitis (11). In a review study, Jones (12) noted that Haller cell was not associated with the pathogenesis of maxillary sinusitis. On the other hand, in another study Haller cell was found to be related to both ethmoid and maxillary mucosal disease (13). Oshima et al. (8) examined the relationship of Haller cell and maxillary sinus FB. They reported that FB was present on both the affected and the unaffected sides, but no significant correlation was detected. In the presented study, Haller cell was detected in both the affected side and the healthy side, indicating no significant correlation between Haller cell and maxillary sinus FB.
Onodi cell is the most common anatomical variant of the posterior ethmoidal air cells that pneumatize superiorly and laterally to the sphenoid sinus (14). To our knowledge, there is no study that investigated the association of Onodi cell and sphenoid sinus FB. In our study, Onodi cell presence was more common on the unaffected sides, but this finding was not significant. However, a significant correlation was present between the lateral recess and FB localization. Sphenoid sinus FB was significantly more common on the same side as the lateral recess. Sphenoid sinus pneumatization can extend into greater wings of the sphenoid bone, resulting in lateral recess. The lateral recess drains into the sphenoethmoidal recess via the sphenoid ostium. The drainage pathway of the lateral recess is against gravity and this situation can lead to difficulty in mucociliary clearance. If suitable environmental conditions are present, the accumulation of fungal spores, which cannot be cleared by the mucosal defense mechanism, can cause FBs.
There are many case reports in the literature that define the association of FB and odontogenic etiologies such as endodontic treatment, dental overfilling, oroantral fistula and dental implant (15, 16, 17, 18, 19). Tomazic et al. (20) investigated the association between dentogenic factors and maxillary sinus FB in 102 patients. They reported that the presence of dentogenic factors was significantly associated with FB compared to the healthy side. However, in the referred study, there was no significant relationship between a single dentogenic factor and FB. Mensi et al. (21) reported that patients who underwent endodontic treatment on the upper premolars, molars, and canines, had a 14-fold increased risk for maxillary sinus FB development. Legent et al. (22) investigated dental canal filling and a fungal sinusitis relationship in 85 patients, 85% of whom had dental overfilling of the maxillary sinus. In our study, maxillary sinus FB was found to be markedly frequent in patients who had dental disease or treatment history. Nevertheless, the relationship of a single dental pathology and maxillary FB localization was not statistically significant. Our results support that a combination of dental pathologies should be present in the same patient for maxillary sinus FB development.
Our study focused on both anatomical variations and odontogenic etiologies. The unaffected side was accepted as the negative control group. For this reason, other risk factors such as systemic disease, smoking, air pollution and occupational exposure, which may play a role in fungal sinusitis development, could not be examined. Fungal sinusitis is a multifactorial disease and cannot be explained via a simple cause-effect relationship. Therefore, further prospective randomized controlled trials with a large number of patients are necessary.
Conclusion
Our study revealed that the maxillary sinus FB were more common on the concave side of the nasal septal deviation. This finding may state the outcomes of the traumatic effects caused by wall shear stress of the high-velocity air flow and the increased possibility of the inhalation of fungal spores. Also, dental pathologies or dental treatment history, regardless of type, were significantly associated with maxillary sinus FB. Patients who have dental disease or have undergone dental treatment should be closely monitored and informed about the possible risk of FB development.
Main Points
• Nasal airflow turbulence and mucociliary clearance dysfunction are extremely important for the pathophysiology of fungal sinusitis.
• Our study revealed that the maxillary sinus FB were more common on the concave side of the nasal septal deviation.
• Dental pathologies or presence of dental treatment history are associated with maxillary sinus FB.
Statistical Analysis
Descriptive statistics were used to describe continuous variables (average, standard deviation, minimum, median and maximum). We determined significant differences by chi-square test and, if suitable, Fisher’s exact test. P-values of <0.05 were assumed to be statistically significant. Statistical analyses were performed with GraphPad Prism (version 8.2.0 for Windows, GraphPad Software, La Jolla, CA, USA).
